Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works?

You’re not a bad parent if you can’t tell whether that tiny bottle of drops or that “all-natural” gripe water is actually helping. Colic and gas are exhausting, and the marketing is loud. Let’s walk through the evidence calmly so you can decide what’s worth trying—and what’s okay to skip.

Based on current research, neither gripe water nor standard simethicone gas drops consistently outperforms placebo for colic or gas in healthy infants.1 3 4 5 Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works? In most cases, time, soothing techniques, and ruling out medical issues matter far more than the product you choose.4 14

Understanding the Science

When you’re desperate at 2 a.m., “Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works?” feels like the most urgent question in the world. To answer it, we need to look at what each product is, and what clinical trials say.

What are gas drops (simethicone)?

Most “gas drops” for babies use simethicone, an inert, surface‑active substance that helps gas bubbles merge so they can be passed more easily.6

Multiple randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews have tested simethicone in infants with colic:

• A crossover trial of 83 infants found no significant difference between simethicone and placebo in colic symptoms.3
• Another trial with 27 infants likewise showed no measurable effect on crying, diary reports, or behavioral observation.6
• Systematic reviews and a Cochrane analysis conclude that simethicone does not reduce crying time or colic compared with placebo, with very low–to–low quality evidence.1 5 14 15

In other words: parents often report improvement, but babies receiving placebo improve just as often.2 3 6 That suggests a strong placebo effect and natural improvement over time, not a reliably active treatment.

What is gripe water?

“Gripe water” is a broad term, usually for a herbal or flavored liquid given for gas or colic. Modern formulations commonly include combinations of:

• Herbal extracts (e.g., fennel, chamomile, ginger)
• Sweeteners (sugar or alternatives)
• Flavorings and preservatives

Older versions contained alcohol, which is not safe for infants and is no longer recommended.

Evidence is much thinner here:

• Reviews of infant colic treatments note no good‑quality randomized trials showing benefit for gripe water in colicky infants.4 5 14
• Herbal agents in general (including those often found in gripe water) are not recommended for infant colic because of limited efficacy data and potential safety concerns.5

So for “Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works?”, the honest answer is that we don’t have strong evidence that either reliably improves colic or normal infant gas.4 5 14

Safety basics

From an evidence‑based, safety‑first standpoint:

• Simethicone gas drops

  • Generally considered low risk and minimally absorbed from the gut.4 6
  • Major guidelines note lack of proven benefit, but no serious harms in typical doses in healthy infants.4 5 12 14

• Gripe water

  • Safety varies by brand and ingredients.
  • Concerns include sugar load, potential contamination, unregulated herbal components, and, in some preparations, unnecessary additives.4 5
  • Major pediatric groups emphasize the lack of evidence and caution against assuming “natural” means safe or effective.4 5

If you’ve read our pieces on Propylene Glycol In Baby Products Safety Breakdown or Formaldehyde Releasers The Hidden Preservatives In Baby Wash, you already know: the ingredient list matters as much as the marketing.

Comparison at a glance

When you ask “Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works?”, you’re really weighing evidence, safety, and practicality:

From a science perspective, that means neither is a magic fix. The question “Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works?” is best reframed as: Which fits my baby’s situation, and is safest, given the limited evidence?

Explore a baby product's ingredients

Free ingredient scanner for parents

Get App

Tips for Parents

Use these practical steps to navigate Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works? without panic:

• Start with non‑medication strategies
  Try paced feeding, frequent burping, upright positioning after feeds, and checking latch or nipple flow. Evidence suggests many colic episodes improve with time and soothing, not specific products.4 14

• Talk to your pediatrician before starting anything
  Persistent crying, poor weight gain, fever, vomiting, or blood in stool need medical evaluation first. Your pediatrician can help rule out reflux, allergy, or infection before you reach for gripe water or gas drops.4 12

• If you try gas drops, use them realistically
  Understand that studies show simethicone is no better than placebo for colic.1 3 4 5 14 15 If you use it, keep doses within label recommendations and monitor whether you truly see a consistent pattern of benefit.

• Be extra cautious with gripe water
  Check for alcohol, high sugar content, questionable herbs, or preservatives. Given the lack of strong evidence for benefit and variability in formulations, use the smallest effective amount—if you use it at all—and stop if you notice any change in feeding, stools, or alertness.4 5

• Prioritize overall ingredient safety
  Just as you would with baby washes or wipes (see Sodium Benzoate In Baby Wipes Is It Dangerous and Formaldehyde Releasers The Hidden Preservatives In Baby Wash), treat gripe water and gas drops as products to scan, not just trust.

• Track patterns, not single nights
  Keep a simple log of crying, feeding, and sleep for a few days before and after trying anything. Colic naturally fluctuates; patterns over time tell you more than one “good” or “bad” evening.4 14

Duckie’s Verdict: Is it safe?

From a calm, safety‑first lens:

• Effectiveness: Current evidence does not show that standard simethicone gas drops or typical gripe water formulations reliably improve infant colic beyond placebo.1 3 4 5 14 15
• Safety: Simethicone is generally low risk in healthy infants; gripe water safety is more variable and ingredient‑dependent.4 5 6 12

Verdict: Caution. For healthy babies with typical colic or gas, these products are optional, not essential. Focus on feeding technique, comfort measures, and ruling out medical concerns first. If you choose to use either, do it under pediatric guidance and with close attention to ingredients.

Unsure about other ingredients? Download the Duckie App to scan instantly. Duckie breaks down preservatives, sweeteners, herbal extracts, and potential irritants in seconds, so you’re not left decoding labels at midnight.

FAQ

Does gripe water work better than gas drops for colic?

Current studies do not show simethicone gas drops outperform placebo for colic, and there are no high‑quality trials proving gripe water is more effective.1 3 4 5 14 15 So for Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works?, neither has strong evidence.

Are gas drops safe for newborns?

Simethicone is minimally absorbed and generally considered low risk in typical doses for healthy infants, but it has not been proven effective for colic.4 6 12 Always check age limits on the label and talk to your pediatrician first.

Is “natural” gripe water safer than medicated gas drops?

“Natural” does not automatically mean safer. Gripe water can contain sugars, herbal extracts, and other additives with limited data in young infants.4 5 Simethicone gas drops are better studied and typically low risk but may not offer meaningful benefit.1 3 4 5 14 15

When should I stop using gripe water or gas drops?

Stop immediately if your baby shows changes in feeding, breathing, alertness, rash, or vomiting, and seek medical care. Given weak evidence of benefit, many parents choose to discontinue once they see no consistent improvement over several days.4 5 14

Not sure about an ingredient?

Scan a supported baby-product barcode for Duckie's proprietary ingredient score and plain-language context. Free on iOS.

Download Free on iOS