A crying, gassy baby can make even confident parents question every bottle, drop, and herbal remedy on the shelf. The good news is that most infant gas is temporary—and you do not need to try every product marketed as a solution.
Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works? Neither has strong evidence for treating colic, but simethicone gas drops are more clearly labeled and studied than gripe water. Research finds simethicone performs no better than placebo for typical colic. Gripe water lacks consistent evidence and varies widely in ingredients, so speak with your pediatrician before using either.1 3 7
Understanding the Science
“Gas” and “colic” are not interchangeable. Babies commonly swallow air while feeding, but crying can also result from hunger, tiredness, reflux, overstimulation, constipation, or normal immature digestion. Colic generally describes recurrent, prolonged crying in an otherwise healthy infant—not a confirmed excess-gas disorder.
What is gripe water?
Gripe water is a liquid supplement that may contain combinations of herbal extracts, sweeteners, sodium bicarbonate, or other ingredients. Formulas differ substantially between brands and countries.
In the United States, gripe water is generally marketed as a dietary supplement rather than an FDA-approved treatment. That means parents should not assume that a product has demonstrated effectiveness for infant colic or undergone the same premarket review as an approved medicine.6 7
Evidence supporting gripe water is limited. One observational study found that its use did not appear to prevent colic and was associated with vomiting and constipation, although this type of study cannot prove that gripe water caused those symptoms.9 The larger concern is inconsistency: two bottles labeled “gripe water” may contain very different ingredients.
What are gas drops?
Most infant gas drops contain simethicone, an anti-foaming ingredient intended to combine small gas bubbles so they can pass more easily. Simethicone is not absorbed into the body in the usual way, but that does not mean every product or dose is automatically appropriate for every baby.
The best available review found no meaningful difference between simethicone and placebo for infant colic, including crying duration or the number of infants who improved.1 3 In other words, gas drops may help a particular baby’s perceived gas discomfort, but research does not support them as a reliable treatment for colic.
| Product | Typical ingredients | Evidence for colic | Main safety consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gripe water | Herbs, sweeteners, bicarbonate, or blends | No consistent high-quality evidence | Ingredients and quality vary |
| Simethicone gas drops | Simethicone | No better than placebo in trials | Follow the exact label and age guidance |
| No medication | Feeding and soothing strategies | Often appropriate for normal developmental fussiness | Seek care when warning signs appear |
Gripe Water vs. Gas Drops: Which Actually Works?
For colic, neither option has convincing evidence of consistent benefit. Simethicone has been evaluated in randomized trials and did not outperform placebo, while gripe water has even less reliable evidence behind it.1 3
For occasional suspected gas, some parents report that simethicone seems helpful. That improvement may be real for an individual baby, may reflect natural settling, or may be related to the comfort routine surrounding administration. A short, pediatrician-approved trial is more reasonable than repeatedly switching between products.
Gripe water deserves extra caution because a “natural” label does not guarantee effectiveness, purity, or suitability for infants. Avoid products containing alcohol, honey, or unnecessary sweeteners. Honey is especially important to avoid before 12 months because of the risk of infant botulism.
Never use an adult gas product, homemade remedy, essential oil, or product intended for another age group. Ask your child’s clinician about any medicine or supplement, particularly if your baby is premature, has a medical condition, takes other medicines, or is younger than the product’s labeled minimum age.
Tips for Parents
- Feed your baby in a position that keeps the head higher than the stomach, when practical.
- Pause to burp during and after feeds; avoid forcing a burp if your baby is comfortable.
- Check that the bottle nipple flow is not too fast, which can increase swallowing of air.
- Keep a simple record of feeds, crying, stools, spit-up, and any product used.
- If you try simethicone, use only the supplied syringe or dropper and follow the package instructions exactly.
- Do not combine several gas or colic products unless your pediatrician specifically recommends it.
- Use calming measures such as holding, gentle rocking, white noise, or a brief change of environment.
- Place your baby on their back in a clear, flat sleep space every time—even if gas seems uncomfortable.
- Contact a clinician promptly for fever in a young infant, green or bloody vomit, blood in the stool, a swollen abdomen, poor feeding, breathing difficulty, unusual sleepiness, dehydration, or inconsolable crying.
A baby who cries frequently still deserves careful evaluation, but frequent crying does not automatically mean something dangerous is wrong. Your pediatrician can help distinguish normal developmental fussiness from reflux, constipation, cow’s-milk protein allergy, infection, or another condition.
Duckie’s Verdict: Is it safe?
Caution. Gripe water is not a proven colic treatment, and its changing ingredient lists make blanket safety claims inappropriate. Simethicone gas drops are more clearly defined and may be reasonable for occasional suspected gas when used exactly as directed, but high-quality evidence does not show that they treat colic better than placebo.1 3 7
If your baby seems comfortable, you do not need to give a product simply because it is advertised. If your baby is distressed, check feeding technique and discuss persistent symptoms with a healthcare professional before starting supplements or medicines.
Unsure about other ingredients? Download the Duckie App to scan instantly.
FAQ
Is gripe water better than gas drops for newborns?
No. Neither has strong evidence for treating colic. Gripe water ingredients vary widely, while simethicone drops have clearer labeling. Ask your pediatrician before giving either product to a newborn.1 7
How quickly do simethicone gas drops work?
If they help, parents may notice an effect around feeding or shortly afterward, but clinical trials do not show reliable benefit for colic. Follow the product label rather than giving extra doses.1 3
Can gripe water cause side effects?
It can. Depending on the formulation, babies may experience vomiting, constipation, allergic reactions, or exposure to unsuitable ingredients. Check the full label and discuss use with your pediatrician.9
When should I call the doctor about baby gas?
Seek medical advice for fever, poor feeding, dehydration, breathing problems, a swollen abdomen, green or bloody vomit, blood in the stool, unusual sleepiness, or persistent inconsolable crying.
Not sure about an ingredient?
Scan a supported baby-product barcode for Duckie's proprietary ingredient score and plain-language context. Free on iOS.
Download Free on iOSSources & References
How this article was made
This article was prepared with AI assistance and edited by Duckie. Sources are listed with the article, but source quality can vary. It has not been medically reviewed unless a named clinician reviewer is shown. Please verify health decisions with a qualified professional.
Medical disclaimer
This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider for guidance specific to your child.
See Duckie's editorial policy and scoring methodology.